Skip to main content

Houston Business Equity & Inclusion Assessment Illustrates Progress, Opportunity to Act

Published Oct 26, 2021 by A.J. Mistretta

dei assessment.JPG

HOUSTON (October 26, 2021) – Houston area companies are largely proactive when it comes to advancing equity and inclusion in their business practices, but many are falling short of adequately addressing the racial, ethnic and gender gaps in the talent pipeline and promoting people of color and women to senior leadership roles and board positions, according to findings from the Houston region’s first Equity & Inclusion Organization Assessment. A total of 120 companies and organizations representing 215,000 employees in the region participated in the assessment conducted by the Greater Houston Partnership, which will use the results to guide its efforts to advance equity and inclusion in the business community. 

The Partnership invited businesses and organizations across the 12-county region to participate in the assessment as a key component of One Houston Together, the organization’s commitment to leverage the power of the business community to reduce inequities in the metro area. The 120 organizations that responded are a representative sample of the region’s private sector companies as well as nonprofits and public entities. While the results reveal areas for focus, they also highlight the range of maturity in the region.

The assessment, based on a tool designed by the Greater Cleveland Partnership, helped responding organizations measure their progress on workforce and leadership, race and gender diversity, supplier diversity, and 15 DEI Best Practice categories. The assessment’s regional baseline is the first of its kind among major U.S. metros and establishes a starting point for advancing equity and inclusion in the Houston area. Key findings of the assessment include: 

  • 35% of Houston organizations are rated as “proactive” across the 15 categories. Technology and financial institutions lead other industry clusters. 
  • People of color and women are underrepresented in senior leadership roles. Racial and ethnic diversity decreases by about half, whereas gender diversity decreases by roughly one-third between workforce and leadership levels. Female representation deteriorates at higher levels across all races. 
  • Hispanic talent is underrepresented at all levels.
  • Houston companies report higher maturity in foundational and internally focused DEI practices, such as recruitment and retention, but lag when it comes to externally focused DEI practices, such as responsible sourcing. 
  • Less than one-third of participants reported on their Minority Business Enterprise (MBE) spending and those that did averaged just 2% of their total market spend on MBEs. On average, responsible sourcing practices were the least mature of the 15 categories among respondents. Note:  Minority Business Enterprise are defined as those with 51% operations owned and controlled by one or more person(s) belonging to the following groups: Black or African American, Hispanic or Latino, American Indian/Indigenous or Asian.
  • Public/Non-profit organizations outperform private sector organizations in addressing racial and gender gaps in new hires and promotions.
  • Houston organizations average at the “proactive” level -- 35% maturity level compared to 100% for best practices
  • Technology, financial institutions, energy, healthcare/life sciences, and professional services are the most mature industries.

The Partnership established a Racial Equity Committee of its board in 2020, which has since adopted guiding principles for racial equity and identified two areas of action for One Houston Together: accelerating the growth of underrepresented businesses and increasing racial equity in the corporate talent pipeline and executive leadership. The committee deployed the assessment to better understand where area businesses are in their equity and inclusion journey and establish a baseline for future advancement. Boston Consulting Group assisted the Partnership in analyzing the results of the assessment, which were released at the DiverseCity Summit on October 26. 

Addressing inequity and ensuring opportunity for all are critical to the long-term economic success of the Houston metro. In the most diverse city in the nation, minority business owners and individuals in the Houston workforce must be afforded the same opportunities for advancement as their peers to sustain the prosperity of the region. Houston organizations recognize the imperative to lead in this work. 

“Advancing opportunity for all is one of the primary pillars of the Partnership’s Houston Next strategic plan aimed at advancing further as a great global city,” said Bob Harvey, President and CEO of the Partnership. “That’s why it was important for us to take this step as the first major metro to establish a regional baseline for where our business community stands on equity and inclusion. We are admittedly not where we want to be, and these results tell us that we have much work to do. However, now we have the knowledge needed to take decisive action. This assessment provides the starting point from which we can move forward.” 

“Today’s business and organization leaders know they need to be doing more when it comes to equity and inclusion, however they’ve lacked a roadmap,” said Ruth Simmons, President of Prairie View A&M University and Co-chair of the Partnership’s Racial Equity Committee. “This assessment tells us that our current hiring and promotion practices are insufficient in addressing the gap in talent diversity, but it also provides us with the tools needed to carry this forward in a constructive way. I believe Houston is poised to make significant progress, but we can’t let the perfect be the enemy of the good.” 

Through One Houston Together, the Partnership will take specific actions to begin tackling the equity challenges in talent and procurement. 

  • Provide an interactive online dashboard for deeper learning and to help CEOs, human resource professionals, diversity and procurement leaders benchmark their organization’s performance within their industry and against other industries 
  • Facilitate industry work groups to align on regional indicators of progress and share best practices for talent advancement, board representation, and supplier diversity
  • Develop industry fact sheets to help companies identify shared ambitions and starting points for action
  • Support organizations to identify strategies as well as set bold goals and track progress on advancement, representation, and supplier diversity.

“Businesses and organizations now have the responsibility to act on the information gathered in the assessment,” said Amy Chronis, Deloitte LLP’s Houston Managing Partner and Partnership Board Chair. “Many organizations are moving in the right direction, and have alignment on what’s needed to create change,” Chronis said. “Real, meaningful change doesn’t happen without collective action and the commitment needed from the business community.” 

See the full assessment results on an interactive dashboard

See the slides below for some of the findings. You can click on each image to enlarge. 

Greater Houston Partnership
The Greater Houston Partnership works to make Houston one of the best places to live, work and build a business. As the economic development organization for the Houston region, the Partnership advances growth across 12 counties by bringing together business and civic-minded leaders who are dedicated to the area’s long-term success. Representing 900 member organizations and approximately one-fifth of the region’s workforce, the Partnership is the place business leaders come together to make an impact. Learn more at Houston.org.

CONTACT:                                                           

A.J. Mistretta
Vice President, Communications     
amistretta@houston.org    
(c) 504-450-3516                         

Related News

Racial Equity

One Houston Together Member Spotlight: Chevron’s Employee Sponsorship Journey

2/28/23
As part of an ongoing effort to showcase success in the retention and advancement of racially diverse talent, the Partnership’s One Houston Together initiative hosted its first roundtable of 2023 featuring a conversation with senior HR leaders from Chevron who discussed the company’s journey to develop a formal employee sponsorship program. Increasing racial equity in the corporate talent pipeline and board leadership is one of the two priorities of One Houston Together alongside increasing spending with Minority Business Enterprises. The roundtable discussions are designed to share best practices and showcase Partnership members that are leading change.  Joyce Beaugh, Senior Manager of Strategy, Planning and Analytics and Michelle A. Snoddy, Senior HR Manager in Petrotechs, shared details on the development and evolution of Chevron’s sponsorship program now in its third year at the energy company.  While traditional mentorship often involves a senior professional providing advice and guidance to a junior professional, sponsorship requires more active advocacy by the senior for  the junior professional’s career advancement, supporting  their aspiration for growth opportunities and a leadership role within an organization.   “In its simplest form, it’s the difference between advice and action,” Snoddy shared with the roundtable participants. “It’s a senior person actually sticking their neck out for another and utilizing their brand to influence that person’s brand.”  Chevron’s journey in sponsorship began several years ago when benchmarking data suggested junior employees might benefit from a formalized sponsorship program that paired them with Chevron’s senior leaders. The company reviewed research and reached out to other businesses and organizations to get examples of successful sponsorship initiatives and decided to pilot their effort with three divisions to gauge effectiveness. They began with a cohort in Finance in 2021 and expanded the program to the Downstream and IT divisions in 2022.  Chevron uses a data-driven approach to identify junior or sponsored employees with strong and sustained performance who may be experiencing headwinds in their advancement. Sponsored employees must be nominated to participate. Each sponsorship cohort runs for a full year and matches between seniors and juniors are done in part through a proprietary software program, with input from business unit leaders to ensure strong matches. Each cohort begins with formal onboarding for both sponsors and sponsored employees to define expectations and foster productive connections.  The size of cohorts and focus vary depending on the business unit, but in one example of positive results: of the 60 matches over two years in Finance, the promotion rate among participants is 44% higher than non-sponsored employees.  Beaugh said it’s important that the senior leaders involved in the program be in a position of power to influence the junior person’s career trajectory and growth opportunities. The company’s extensive data informs where there are breakdowns in advancement within business units and where sponsorship might be most effective. Long term success metrics for the sponsorship program include increased depth and diversity of talent pipeline and measuring participant career progression and employee satisfaction. “No one is successful without help,” Snoddy said. “Informal sponsorship has been happening for generations, but it hasn’t happened for everyone. We’re taking that informal relationship and formalizing it so that others who might be experiencing headwinds on their journey get the same opportunities.”  In addition to the conversation with Chevron, the roundtable also featured a presentation by Sadie Funk, National Director of Best Place for Working Parents®. The Partnership is the Houston region sponsor for the campaign that enables companies to assess the family-friendliness of their policies and receive a special designation based on their results.  The brief 3-minute survey allows companies to self-assess across 10 research-backed policies that benefit both working parents and the company’s bottom line. Houston companies on the whole ranked high in more than half of the categories in the organization’s 2022 National Trends Report. Best Places is currently active in 14 cities across nine states. Funk highlighted why Best Place for Working Parents® policies are important in today’s post-COVID working environment and they will be in the future:  60% of non-working parents say childcare is the top reason they do not participate in the workforce.  Only 27% of families have the father as the sole breadwinner. 73% of highly credentialed women who leave the workforce say they would have stayed had they had access to flexibility at work.  83% of millennials say they will leave one job for another with stronger family policies and supports.  Replacing an employee costs a business six to nine months of that employee’s salary on average.  Learn more about One Houston Together and read about other case studies.  Want to join the Talent Roundtable? C-suite and senior HR/Talent/DEI leaders from Partnership member companies, please email DEIAssessment@houston.org.  
Read More
Human Resources and Talent Event

Report: Houston Companies Lead When it Comes to Family-Friendly Workplace Policies

1/18/23
A recent research study assessing family-friendly policies at companies in 15 U.S. metros shows that Houston ranks high in six of 10  areas, from employee and dependent healthcare offerings to paid parental leave and remote work.  The 2022 Best Place for Working Parents® National Trends Report examines the benefits and policies of businesses that promote family-friendly work environments and their competitive advantage in attracting and retaining employees. Participating companies were surveyed about their policies across 10 proven practices shown to be effective in supporting working parents as well as businesses’ bottom line. Houston is one of 15 metros that participated and a total of 65 companies in the Houston region completed the survey prior to September 21, 2022. Southern Methodist University’s Center on Research and Evaluation collaborated with Best Place for Working Parents® to complete the report.  Fifteen industries were represented among the Houston survey participants, with the highest participation in the nonprofit, professional services and finance & insurance sectors. Companies of all sizes participated, including large (29%), mid-sized (30%), small (27%) and micro (14%) organizations.  Houston ranks among the top 3 metros for the following policies: Employee and Dependent Healthcare Paid Time Off Parental Leave  Nursing Benefits Child Care Assistance Remote Work LaTanya Flix, Senior Vice President of Diversity, Equity and Inclusion for the Partnership, led the launch of the assessment in 2022. “The results are compelling because the Houston region has not been recognized as a leader in this area. It is exciting to see our companies’ efforts recognized and to know how we compare to other regions," Flix said. "The findings demonstrate that Houston area companies are implementing proven practices that benefit families, increase employee retention, and ultimately make their companies more competitive. We have momentum in Houston and the Best Place for Working Parents® assessment is a useful tool to support companies in continuing to develop, implement, and improve their policies and practices." In addition to providing a view on the current policy environment, the national report also sought to evaluate the success of implementing the top ten policies in creating family-friendly workplaces across size and industry, and what changes had occurred in these policies pre- and post-COVID. Several key findings from the report include: Most family-friendly companies offer healthcare, paid time off, remote work, and flexible work policies. 90% of Best Place for Working Parents designees have these policies because they are affordable and effective, whereas onsite child care and backup child care are the least frequently offered. Larger companies offer a wider range of family-friendly benefits, whereas smaller companies are focused on a few benefits that have a very high impact. An organization's ability to implement policies increases with its size. Micro and small organizations, however, are also capable of implementing a range of the top ten family-friendly policies and are above average in implementing high-impact benefits, such as on-site child care and backup child care. On average, Business & Information and Finance & Insurance organizations offer more family-friendly benefits compared to other industries surveyed. Business & Information and Finance & Insurance organizations each offer five family-friendly benefits above the national average, which is more than any of the other industries surveyed. “In order to create workplaces that are both family-friendly and business-friendly, we must first understand the specific needs, trends, and challenges of Best Place for Working Parents businesses across each industry and organization size. With the ability to benchmark a company's performance against similar organizations, business leaders can gain insights on best practices in recruiting and retaining employees and identify tangible ideas for how to implement research-backed family-friendly policies in their own organizations,” said Sadie Funk, national director of The Best Place for Working Parents.  View the complete report here and take the assessment here.   
Read More

Related Events

Demography

One Houston Together Assessment Kickoff

Kickoff the Biennial Houston Regional Equity & Inclusion Assessment with the Partnership!  Join us to:  Network with…

Learn More
Learn More
Executive Partners